
What does risk management look like in the nascent sustainable fusion industry? The latest Airmic Field Trip offers members rare insight into the cutting edge of science.
“What we are creating here in Culham is the sun on earth,” explains Nicola Barber, who leads the group risk and assurance function at the UK Atomic Energy Authority, the government’s fusion national laboratory for sustainable fusion energy research and development.
The UKAEA’s core mission is to lead the commercial development of low-carbon fusion power, aiming to have the world’s first prototype fusion power plant running by the early 2040s. The technology is a long way from being commercially scalable, but its proponents believe it could become a multi-trillion-pound global industry in the second half of the century.
“It’s the same energy nuclear reaction that is in the sun and the stars. It’s the most energy dense form of energy there is on earth – and it is low-carbon and sustainable. It could solve the world’s energy needs,” explains Barber.
This November, Airmic members will have the opportunity to visit the site, near Oxford, and learn about how risk is managed in a truly innovative environment on the cutting edge of global science.
Nuclear fusion: the risk profile
Although they sound similar, nuclear fusion is entirely different from the nuclear energy that is currently used in the global energy mix. Nuclear energy involves splitting atoms – nuclear fission – and has a much higher hazard profile due to the risk of a widespread nuclear chain reaction and high active waste inventory.
By comparison, nuclear fusion, as the name suggests, involves combining light atomic nuclei to form a heavier nucleus releasing a huge amount of energy in the process. In the absence of the gravitational force present in the sun, this reaction requires an immense amount of heat – up to 150 million degrees, which is ten times hotter than the sun.
“It’s impossible for a fusion power plant to trigger a nuclear chain reaction so it’s much safer than nuclear fission. But achieving sustained high temperatures along with other huge technical hurdles is very challenging so it is not yet commercially viable,” says Barber.
In a future fusion powerplant (FPP), a key area of risk relates to the use of tritium to trigger reactions. This is a radioactive fuel, highly transferable both in air and water.
The amount of tritium fuel in an FPP is very small and will be mostly locked up in structural materials, which reduces the potential for exposure, explains Barber.
The amount of tritium in mobile form – e.g. gaseous or as tritiated water – is even smaller, and will be tightly controlled by engineered safety measures, such as confinement.
“Containment is key to managing the risk, and this is built into the design of the power plant itself,” says Barber.
Some of the risk measures in place include a large in-house health physics laboratory and service with over 60 specialists onsite to perform lab-testing, combined with heavy use of robotics:
“We're developing the capability so that the FPP will be remotely controlled, including the maintenance of the power plant so it doesn't have to shut down for days every time a part needs replacing. It’s both for safety and efficiency.”
Airmic Field Trip: unique insight
From managing the risks of data centres and robotics to AI and power plant regulation, Barber believes risk professionals from other sectors can learn a lot from the UKAEA Field Trip:
“It’s interesting to see how risk is managed in cutting edge projects. Risk management is deeply embedded in all we do. For example, our risk and assurance partners sit within the programmes alongside the directors and scientists, not in the corporate centre. It gives us the flexibility to manage the tension between innovation and safety.”
Beyond the specialist nuclear-related risks, there is also a broad crossover with other sectors. “Our other hazards are similar to any major industrial programme and our hazard map reflects the World Economic Forum’s top global threats. I think for any risk professional it’s helpful to see how risk is managed in adjacent sectors.”
For more information about the UKAEA Field Trip and to register, click here. This is a member-only event and spaces are limited.